Robert D. Kaplan’s “The Tragic Mind”

This short book is one of Kaplan’s most personal. Kaplan has been a foreign correspondent and has written many books about the struggles of politics under the tyranny of geography in faraway places. Unlike most of his other works, “The Tragic Mind” is about himself. It is not an autobiography; instead mostly an essay about what Kaplan learned about human nature and world politics during his decades with a front row seat to humanity’s struggle.

Kaplan’s conclusion, the world is (and has always been) in a seismic struggle between two forces: order and chaos. Drawing deeply from the ancients, he identifies the Dionysiac and the Apolline. As soon as we recognize this, we must immediately begin to understand that the world really is one large Greek Tragedy. Not a catastrophe (we mis-diagnose what a tragedy is). A tragedy is the realization that the world is imperfect, that there are no heroes and villains, just people trying to do the best they can for the interests they are trying to preserve, and that Dionysus is waiting around every turn. Or to put it simply, to walk humbly because the “unknown unknowns” are many and every decision we make can unleash the chaos which might consume us.

“While civilization is the culmination of our struggle to realize our humanity and to rid ourselves of our propensity for violence and the iron grip of fate, we can only achieve this by never losing sight of our origins. But that is only possible by deliberately cultivating insecurity, whose broad basis is a respect for chaos: something impossible unless one thinks tragically.”

This book is about danger, the danger for the United States and the world as the wealthiest, most protected, most isolated generation that ever existed – who know no wars or no depressions or any real danger product of battle – saunter onto the world stage with only opinions and prejudices and without any sense of the tragic that their actions might evoke. I know exactly what Kaplan is talking about here; while he huddled in trenches as a correspondent, I spent more than 20 years in dangerous places running programs against Hugo Chavez and ISIS and Putin. I went out, early on, copy of Natan Sharansky’s “Case for Democracy” under my arm, convinced my struggle was “Freedom against Tyranny” AND I WAS THE GOOD GUY!! That didn’t last, as I came to understand that the danger was not a mismanaged election but the “Arriving Ordeal” as I saw it in West Africa, Kaplan’s Dionysus present everywhere and rapidly advancing.

The preservation of order – we in the US Government called it “Stabilization”.

Kaplan wrote about the coming anarchy in his books, and they touched a chord with me. Because, having been around the world and had my teams attacked by terrorists, people I knew killed or died, hunkered in place with my 3 year old while bullets flew – I know the fear Kaplan honestly talks about; I know what disorder looks like. I also wrote about it, mostly in novels where the main characters were somehow always the bad guys. Not anti-heroes, nor villains, but victims of the chaos and responding in the only way they were able. Because that is something that is also true, that Kaplan doesn’t talk too much about, but the chaos comes because options are so very limited for the poor in the world. We in the US see democracy as about choices – choices for everything: what I should wear or watch or play with, even now to the bizarre ‘hmm what gender am I today?’ (which itself is Dionysian in the most profound, Nietzschean sense).

At the end of Val Kilmer’s rendition of “Island of Dr. Moreau”, David Thewlis channels H.G. Wells, “…and those times I look around me at my fellow man and I am reminded of some likeness of the beast people, and I feel as though the animal is surging up in them, and they are neither wholly animal or wholly man but an unstable combination of both, as unstable as anything Moreau created, and I go in fear.”

About Joel D. Hirst

Joel D. Hirst is a novelist and a playwright. His most recently released work is "Dreams of the Defeated: A Play in Two Acts" about a political prisoner in a dystopian regime. His novels include "I, Charles, From the Camps" about the life of a young man in the African camps and "Lords of Misrule" about the making and unmaking of a jihadist in the Sahara. "The Lieutenant of San Porfirio" and its sequel "The Burning of San Porfirio" are about the rise and fall of socialist Venezuela (with magic).
This entry was posted in America, Book Review and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Robert D. Kaplan’s “The Tragic Mind”

  1. Pingback: Kaplan on Order | Joel D. Hirst's Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s