I Don’t Read Fiction

“I don’t usually read fiction” I was recently told by a friend of mine, “but I’ll make an exception for you,” the comment delivered with sufficient condescension to communicate that I had just become the recipient of an unlikely favor.

I get that comment a lot, especially from people who aspire to the distinction of intellectuals, policymakers, activists or thought leaders.  It’s as if somehow the vociferous rejection of this particular art form is a credential that substantiates their position in society.  Yet the comment never fails to baffle me.  Unlike literature, I meet very few people who energetically assert that they “never look at a painting” or that they “don’t listen to music.”  Yet, when it comes to a novel people feel that the unwillingness to enjoy a well-written story is evidence of some sort of superiority.

To be sure, there are a lot of poorly written novels out there (mine probably among them), and a lot of popular fiction is either obscene in an attempt to be provocative or ‘action packed’ in an attempt at pandering.  But isn’t this also the case for other art forms – and isn’t it perhaps a matter of opinion?  I, for example, do not like modern art and am not a fan of impressionism; but this does not mean that I don’t enjoy walking through the MET or the Art Institute of Chicago eagerly searching for something that touches my soul.  Neither do I enjoy rap or country music; but this does not mean that I do not seek out the folksy tunes of Paul Simon or the passionate ballads of Ricardo Arjona in my desire to be carried away.  Does my dislike of particular genres in any way affect their value to others?  And why should searching out a novel to enjoy be different?

And I often wonder if this has always been the case.  Did Leo Tolstoy’s friends turn him down when he presented them a copy of War and Peace?  Did W. Somerset Maugham have a nose turned up at him after penning Of Human Bondage?  Was J.R.R. Tolkien seen as the dunce of Oxford because he wrote fantasy (the word itself used with a disdainful smirk)?  I don’t know; perhaps.  Maybe it’s always been thus.

But I can’t help thinking, whatever the answer, that it’s a sign of troubled times.  Just like other art, good literary fiction has a special way of challenging the reader as they are transported to another place.  Gabriel Garcia Marquez gave us Macondo; a prototypical Latin American village where we could try and grapple with problems of poverty and violence and injustice as we interacted with his colorful characters.  Jonathan Swift challenged the omnipotence of the king of England.  Through Magical Realism we are brought to see the ridiculous in our political systems; through fantasy we engage in a binary world where evil fights good for world domination; through epic Victorian literature we are brought into the inner stories of the characters as they struggle for virtue and morality in a difficult period in history; and in Hemingway’s travels we experience firsthand the shock of the bizarre in cultures that are foreign to our own.  Each experience deepens us, makes us more honest and somehow sharper.  And they carry us away, filling us with new perspectives and understandings.

This is why I love to read, and to write.  As I try and describe what I see and feel, I find in my humdrum normality something epic.  I divorce myself from my daily life, rising above the administrative challenges and petty conflicts to gaze down and see the story as it could be – as it should be.  Using what I see around me, I fill out my characters – making them human but so much more so.  To be sure, I have been blessed; I have lived in faraway places and only need to take a deep breath and step back to narrate a story that is amazing (assuming I can tell it right).  This does not make my writing better; it makes it worse.  Like Hemingway (I’m going to share a dark secret here – I have never been able to finish any of Hemingway’s books), the thing that makes the stories are surroundings that are alien to the reader.  A good writer – a really good writer – can go so much farther, taking things that are ordinary to the reader and filling them with magic.  This is what Carlos Ruiz Zafon and Mario Vargas Llosa do; and it is what makes their writing great.

For those who claim they do not – I entreat you, read fiction.  Read it to be swept away, to be challenged and to be inspired.  Lose yourself in parallel worlds; and if you dare, write – shaping a universe as you would like it to be.  You will not find that you have ‘wasted time’ – but maybe that in point of fact ‘real life’ is the true waste.

Joel D. Hirst is the author of “The Lieutenant of San Porfirio” and the upcoming sequel “The Burning of San Porfirio”

About Joel D. Hirst

Joel D. Hirst is a novelist and a playwright. His most recently released work is "Dreams of the Defeated: A Play in Two Acts" about a political prisoner in a dystopian regime. His novels include "I, Charles, From the Camps" about the life of a young man in the African camps and "Lords of Misrule" about the making and unmaking of a jihadist in the Sahara. "The Lieutenant of San Porfirio" and its sequel "The Burning of San Porfirio" are about the rise and fall of socialist Venezuela (with magic).
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to I Don’t Read Fiction

  1. ianmathie says:

    Politicians who claim that they don’t read fiction must be deluding themselves. They read it every day in most of the official documentation they digest with such diligence. The trouble is, they’re in denial and don’t recognise the fictitious premises on which their policies are based. That having been said, on or two politicians have gone on, after retiring from politics, to write quite creditable novels, usually about crime. Well, they have an inside track, don’t they?
    I have to confess to being one of those who has said I don’t read a particular genre. But then along comes someone with something interesting and a little different, but still in the genre I don’t read, and I’m hooked. I’ve since read and reviewed a fair number of books in that genre (romantic fiction). It’s the same with magical realism: whilst I had read a number of books in the genre, well one couldn’t ignore Marquez, if only for the quality of the writing, I had never considered that my own writing might relate to the genre. And then someone suggested I look at Zoe Brooks’s blog and your work, and it opened whole new horizons. I may be writing mainly memoir, but there is a lot of magic in it, much of it far stranger than fiction, so perhaps I ought to reclassify them.
    Now, I seldom ask what genre a book is – the word doesn’t roll off the tongue that easily anyway. But I want to know if it has a good story, whether it is well written, and if it will grasp my attention and involve me. That’s good, because it seldom lets me down, although like you with Hemingway, I do occasionally come across a book I just can’t finish.
    Thanks for an interesting and thought provoking blog.


  2. There are those individuals who have little imagination and think they have no time or inclination for the trivial. These often place fiction in the “trivial” and disdain it as unworthy of their time. A pox on them. In a way I pity these folks. They are missing out on so much of the richness that makes life livable. Personally I read fiction almost exclusively. Note I said “almost” because to do the reverse of what those folks do would also rob me of so much.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Pingback: Of Rand and Chernyshevsky | Joel D. Hirst's Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s